The Benchmark of Benchmarks: When the Auditor Is Also the Accused
On July 8, OpenAI published a detailed audit of SWE-bench Pro — the benchmark they had championed just months earlier as the successor to SWE-bench Verified — and found that roughly 30% of its 731 public tasks are broken. The issues fall into four categories: tests so strict they reject correct solutions, prompts so underspecified that hidden requirements are unguessable, tests with coverage so thin that incomplete fixes pass, and prompts that actively mislead. This from a benchmark Scale AI built using…