Optics, Piracy and the Credibility Trial
Fair use is a doctrine until someone writes down what you really thought you were doing. I keep coming back to three words from the newly unsealed filings, where an OpenAI researcher is described as being "worried about optics" over continued use of LibGen for a book summarisation project. That is not legal language. It is reputation language. The Authors Guild is now asking the court to hear it as consciousness of illegality, and that move is why this week matters. The case the Guild is selling is no longer just…